The Refresh TestApr 10 2014
How many times has the following happened to you?
You go to a web site and it asks you to create an account. You fill out a form with all the obvious fields and hit submit. The page refreshes and shows you the form again.
Phone Number is required
Well, that’s annoying. There was no indication that the site needed your phone number. You prefer not to give out your phone number to every web site, but this one is run by a company you trust, so you scroll down and fill it out. You submit the form again.
Password is required
What the heck!? You already entered a password! You scroll down to the form and see that the fields are now empty. It turns out that even though you filled out the password fields the first time, after you missed the phone number they were cleared. You fill them out and submit the form again.
Username is not available
At this point you’re ready to throw your computer out the window. There are fewer things more frustrating than trying to get your data into the exact shape a web site wants, especially if it clears fields every time you fail.
Another annoyance: just about every time I order something online, right after I input my credit card information, I am presented with a spinner animation and the text “Do not hit the back button or refresh your browser!” It’s terrifying that a company that is taking my money over the Internet can’t handle me refreshing the page without charging my card twice.
The sad thing is that both of these problems are totally solvable. In fact, they’ve been easy to solve for over a decade. Yet you still see them all the time.
Lessons from Live Reloading
Recently I spent some time playing with Ember App Kit. Ember App Kit is a suggested project structure for your applications built by Stefan Penner (and a bunch of other awesome developers). It’s really great and if you’ve never tried it out you should!
One feature Ember App Kit includes out of the box is support for connect-livereload, which automatically reloads your changes in your browser whenever you save a file.
It sounds like a minor thing, but after using it for a few hours having to manually hit Cmd-R feels like a chore. It’s a great little productivity booster.
Live Reload also has a side effect: it encourages you to make your application refresh resistant.
In my application I had a multi-step wizard where you had to enter many form fields at once, and I found it so frustrating to have all my form data pulled out from underneath me every time I hit save.
The frustration led me to persist the form data temporarily in localStorage. Once I did that, every time my application refreshed it looked exactly the same as it did before. It was probably a grand total of 10 minutes of work, and my application was much more resilient for it.
The Refresh Test
Users will put up with losing a small amount of state on refresh, for example if they’d expanded a menu and it’s suddenly collapsed, but you should never throw away what they were working on.
One thing I love about Ember.js is that its router makes you think in terms of URLs, which gives you a great head start for handling refreshes and the dreaded back button.
Many people think of URLs as files, because in the past requesting a path like
profile.php?id=eviltrout meant you really wanted a file on the server
profile.php with the parameter
I find it’s better to think of a URL as the serialized state of your
application. A path of
/profiles/eviltrout should mean “I’m viewing
I’m not suggesting that the URL contain every possible interaction a user can make; if you do that you will end up with a huge headache and a meaningless URL. Instead, you should focus on the most important things a user will want to see when the page is refreshed. For example, on Discourse we maintain a user’s scroll position in a topic by changing the URL as they scroll.
Going forward, I’m going to make sure that all my applications handle refreshing elegantly and I recommend you do too! If you’re interested in more on this topic, Tom Dale has a great talk on this called Stop Breaking the Web.
1. If you’re a fan of using bleeding edge stuff, check out Stefan Penner’s ember-cli and Jo Liss' broccoli. Ember App Kit works well today but those projects are a glimpse of the future of where Ember development is headed.